Disc Specs

  • Region:
    ALL
  • Released:
    16th November 2009
  • Country:
    United Kingdom
  • Running Time:
    97 minutes
  • Screen Format:
    2.40:1 / 1080P / AVC/H.264/MPEG4
  • Discs / Type:
    1 / BD50
  • Soundtracks:
    DTS HD MA 5.1
    Thai
    Director and crew commentary
    Producer and director commentary
  • Subtitles:
    English
    Chinese
    Hindi
    Indonesian
    Thai
    English (for both commentaries)
  • Special Features:
    Director and crew commentary
    Producer and director commentary
    Whistle (28:46, 480P)
    The making of Moon (16:18, 480P)
    creating the visual FX (11:09, 480p)
    Science center Q&A (20:48, 1080i)
    Filmmakers Q&A at Sundance (11:15, 1080P)
    Trailer (2:08, 1080P)
    Trailers:
    2012 (1:08, 1080P)
    Ghostbusters (1:23, 1080P)
    Julie and Julia (2:11, 1080P)
    Angels and Demons (1:08, 1080P)
    GERTY Table Tennis Easter Egg
  • Distributor:
    Sony

Film Specs

  • Certificate:
    15
  • Released:
    2009
  • Country:
    United Kingdom
  • Director:
    Duncan Jones
  • Starring:
    Sam Rockwell
    Dominique McElligott
    Matt Berry
    Benedict Wong
    Kevin Spacey (voice)
  • Genre(s):
    Science Fiction

Best Prices


Amazon UK
£10.98

HMV
£10.99

Shopto
£12.80

The Hut
£12.85

Zavvi
£12.85

Moon

16-11-2009 00:00 | 6567 views  |  John White  |  Show Backlinks  |  Other "Moon" Content

The Film

Have you ever wondered just what kind of person takes those jobs situated in the middle of nowhere where they barely see anyone? What kind of person chooses to be so cut off from civilised company, distant from all they love and all whom they care for? Who would choose to go somewhere so far from validation, emotional satisfaction and the reassurance of your image reflected in the eyes of another?
Duncan Jones' dad, David Bowie, once pondered the sadness of such isolation in much the same way as he praise the qualities of jocular little people - "Planet Earth is blue and there's nothing I can do". It seems highly appropriate that his son's debut feature deals with the isolation that comes from separation from the earthly as Sam Bell orbits our Earth from the lonely vantage point of a moon mining base.

Sam Bell has only Kevin Spacey's voice for company and looks forward to his wife's messages for news of home. Yet he knows that something is wrong and after recovering from a crash in a moon buggie, he escapes quarantine to find that the buggie is still there and that there is a very familiar looking occupant still alive inside it. Soon, Sam's own nature and existence are exposed and we discover that he is the answer to the question that begins my review.
Sam is fit for the purpose of the disposable needs of his employers, and in some way an echo of the characters that Ian Holm played in Alien and Lance Henriksen in the sequel. Bell's growing awareness of himself and his desire to snatch a real life whilst he can become the key topics for Moon. And in that sense, Duncan Jones' indie sci-fi movie is not as novel as it would like to be. Solaris, A:I, Alien and the like have all entered similar territory of mining a sense of human redundancy. There are twists on the films that have gone before but the roots of the story are not all that different to HAL 9000 deciding humans were expendable or the use of the crew of the Nostromo as bait in Scott's movie.

This is quite an achievement for a debut, however. The use of model effects is well executed, the design of Sam's living space is very competent, and to have an actor of Rockwell's talents at the centre of things is a very shrewd choice. This is though a familiar piece more than an inventive one. The music score by Clint Mansell is certainly after the work on Soderbergh's Solaris, Gerty the onboard computer is a flip on HAL 9000 with its conmspiratorial approach, and the sense of an exploitative multinational putting profit before people is any number of sci-fi movies from the last 40 years.
Still, familiarity isn't always a bad thing and I can forgive a sometimes artless exposition to enjoy the film and Rockwell in particular. Moon shows that the British film industry still has some talent and some good ideas, even if they recall past glories, and you could do a lot worse than lassoe a copy now.

Technical Specs

Moon is transferred at 2.40:1 and presented in the MPEG-4 codec. The image is understandably desaturated with the preponderance of shades, contrast is impeccable, grain is barely discernible and detail is very good. Edge enhancement is not an issue and backgrounds are left as soft as they are meant to be given the mode of shooting. This a strong clean transfer that shows off the film very well.
The master audio track uses the range of speakers most extensively during the high points of the score and where the ambience of the living quarters is emphasised. There are very few moments of action so dialogue moving around the soundstage is not all that noticeable. The bit rate is very healthy and for such a low budget movie, this is a rich soundtrack with atmosphere well defined and reproduced.

Special features

Duncan Jones is present on both the commentary tracks with the collaboraton with producer Stuart Fenegan being much more sober than the one with the DP, concept and production designers. For me I enjoyed the more blokey jokey commentary with Jones being ribbed for his original script - "Sammy and the clones"! There's plenty on each track about how the effects were achieved on a budget of just $5million and how difficult choices were made, alongside some of the improvements made in editing.

Jones' short Whistle is included from 2002. The story deals with a family man and fixer of assassinations whose latest assignment leads to collateral damage and a re-examination of his life. It feels a bit vague and unfinished but there's definitely talent here.

The making of includes interviews, shooting footage from Shepperton and much of blue and green screen work. Rockwell praises Jones' passion and believes "fairy dust" has been sprinkled on the project, and Jones praises the drive of his team. The visual FX featurette is introduced by Simon Stanley-Clamp from Cinesite who did the effects on the film and he reveals the work done with composite shots and the switching between CGI and models for Gerty.

There are two Q&A's with the director included in HD. At Sundance, the questions are from film buffs and at the science center they are from... well you can imagine! The Sundance piece turns into a thankathon which gets a little tiresome. A theatrical trailer in HD completes the film based extras.

Trailers for other Sony product are the final inclusions.

Summary

A fine debut but don't buy that this is an equal to the likes of Alien or Blade Runner. A very good transfer and strong extras await the hi-def viewer

Please help support DVD Times by purchasing this title or any others through our affiliate links...

Amazon UK
£10.98
HMV
£10.99
Shopto
£12.80
The Hut
£12.85

DVD Times Ratings

  • Film:
    7
    7 out of 10
  • Video: 
    8
    8 out of 10
  • Audio: 
    8
    8 out of 10
  • Extras: 
    7
    7 out of 10
  • Overall: 
    7
    7 out of 10

Reader Ratings

  • Film 
    8.4
  • Video 
    7.7
  • Audio 
    8
  • Extras 
    6
  • Overall 
    8.3

Comments

#1 Posted: 18-11-2009 15:03
bburdett
Member
Posts: 66

Report this post
I really enjoyed this film at the cinema and bought the blu-ray on Monday, the transfer is very good indeed, really showed off how good a non-CGI filled film looks in HD. Can't really argue with your review, though I feel it deserves a higher score, I enjoyed it more than Solaris for sure. Haven't watched any of the special features but the amount of them appears to be very good indeed, looking forward to watching the making of and the science center Q&A I read about before the release.
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 18-11-2009 16:17
john white
Contributor
Posts: 181

Report this post
I wasn't very precise about Solaris above, I like both versions and age has led me to enjoy the Tarkovsky one far more as I appreciate the slowburn more than when I was younger. It's really only the score of Moon that recalls Soderbergh's version, it owes more to Tarkovsky as Noel's cinema review points out.
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 19-11-2009 09:42
bburdett
Member
Posts: 66

Report this post
Sorry, for some reason when typing I completely forgot you only mentioned Solaris in regards to the score, and in that I can agree with you :)
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 02-12-2009 13:38
ShawnDuHast
Grave Wisdom
Posts: 376

Report this post
Good review as ever John!

It is a good film but for an 8 rating on imdb I was expecting a little more, not special effects as I do appreciate their budget but just a bit more to the story.

This is a though, a very professional first entry on a directors CV!
------

Metal Damage, Brain Damage...Are you listening Bronze? I am the Nightrider. I'm a Fuel Injected Suicide Machine......

Quote this post
#5 Posted: 05-01-2010 17:04
gwyneth45
Member
Posts: 30

Report this post
Saw this in the cinema and really enjoyed it - just bought it on Blu-ray today and looking forward to seeing it again. From my memories of seeing it in the cinema I'd say a 7 is about right and total agree that it's not in the same league as Alien/Blade Runner; a good review for a very solid and enjoyable film.

The following text contains spoilers. Click and drag over this box to view.
Just a small note on the review, the first paragraph under Special Features were you quote "Sammy and the clones" - is a bit of a spoiler if you don't know the story/ending. HTH.
Quote this post