Film Specs

  • Certificate:
    15
  • Running Time:
    78 minutes
  • Released:
    2003
  • Country:
    United States of America
  • Director:
    Gus Van Sant
  • Starring:
    Alex Frost
    Eric Deulen
    John Robinson
    Elias McConnell
    Jordan Taylor
    Carrie Finklea
    Nicole George
    Brittany Mountain
    Alicia Miles
    Kristen Hicks
    Bennie Dixon
  • Genre(s):
    Drama

Elephant

29-01-2004 14:30 | 5804 views  |  Richard Booth

Teen angst and adolescent problems have been very well documented in recent years on celluloid, with teen comedies and dramas popping up at a rate of knotts. One film that came from under the radar to receive much acclaim at the most recent Cannes Film Festival - and win the coveted Palme d'Or award - was Gus Van Sant's Elephant.

Van Sant, recently dabbling in indie cinema with the poorly-received Gerry, tells a story based on the horrific Columbine high school massacre of the '90s that rocked America and the world. An example of teen problems amplified into elephantine proportions, the two kids who shot dead their peers and teachers have now been propelled onto the big screen.

After Michael Moore's documentary Bowling for Columbine tried to ask why did such an event occur, Van Sant now shows what happened at the school on the fateful day - and just who was affected. Although the events in Elephant are not directly related to the real Columbine massacre, the names of the characters are similar and so is the way in which the tragedy unfolded.

Alex and Eric are a literal example of the spiralling hate and despair in youngsters these days, bullied and misunderstood by their classmates and teachers. Through their friendship and common interests, they hatch a plan to get even: and their school must pay.



I don't know the full story behind Columbine, although it was apparently fuelled by Nazi influence, violent video games and other such media that can corrupt people's minds nowadays. Van Sant doesn't dwell on answering why or how this happened, but does suggest that video games and the ease of ordering firearms in the US is partly to blame for their actions.

Elephant is a snapshot of a day at the high school in Oregon that all the characters attend, and through flashbacks and flashforwards the characters' individual quirks and troubles unfold. There isn't a main character per se, as each person becomes developed and rounded as the short running time allows. There are the popular kids, there are the intelligent kids, there are the isolated 'loners' - but Van Sant allows each person to become real onscreen, and not just some two-dimensional cliché.

The film's greatest strength is the chilling and unsettling feeling it gives you when the credits roll; there are no real answers or solutions offered to this increasing problem, but instead it tries to show you who is affected and how. It isn't gratuitous, but it does show the brutality and callousness that an event such as the Columbine massacre will possess.

Superbly directed - with even the cast of non-professional actors giving their all - this is an original and unnerving cinematic experience that deserves to be seen. People may not like it, but there is no denying Van Sant's skill and talent as a filmmaker in drawing the audience into the tragedy. Recommended.

DVD Times Ratings

  • Overall: 
    8
    8 out of 10

Reader Ratings

  • Overall: 
    7

Comments

#1 Posted: 29-01-2004 18:00
bradavon
Banned
Posts: 2907

Report this post
Thanks for this Rik.

I've been looking forward to seeing this for some time now.

The day (and if it happens) the UK get guns in the hands of police as a routine is the day I'll leave for sure.

What I mean by this is, America for all it's pros and cons is clearly too interested in the gun (I still can't believe you get a free gun when opening a bank account, that should be illegal :confused: ) and such things as Police carrying guns only adds fuel to the fire, IMO.
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 29-01-2004 18:07
Richard Booth
Contributor & Filmmaker
Posts: 980

Report this post
Thanks for the comment Brad.

Hmm...I am now thinking that arming the regular policeman could be a good thing; it might put some fear into criminals and also protect the policemen and the possible victims. On the flipside, it could mean that the criminals will think that they must 'shoot to escape', as the police will be returning fire.

Anyway, back onto Elephant...a great film, as I said in my review, so go and enjoy it Brad. I was pleasantly surprised, even though I was expecting a good film, so hopefully you will be as well. The DVD will turn up on these shores around July, I think.
------
We do not tell time, time only tells us.
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 29-01-2004 19:40
bradavon
Banned
Posts: 2907

Report this post
The criminals shooting back is what I was refering too.

It's still a few weeks before the UK release of Elephant I think?
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 29-01-2004 20:02
Mr_Gimp
Account Disabled
Posts: 5

Report this post
I was really looking forward to this film, but there was always a nagging doubt in the back of my mind that it would fall back on the whole "videogames trained them to kill" argument. Can you provide more detail about this aspect of the movie, Rik? I don't particularly feel like paying money to have this frankly derogatory viewpoint shoved down my throat by another movie.
Quote this post
#5 Posted: 29-01-2004 21:28
Slarek
Member
Posts: 74

Report this post
The title, by the way, appears to have been borrowed from Alan Clarke's brilliantly minimalist 1989 TV drama of the same name about sectarian killing in Northern Ireland. The two films would make a harrowing but thought-provoking double-bill.
Quote this post
#6 Posted: 29-01-2004 21:44
Richard Booth
Contributor & Filmmaker
Posts: 980

Report this post
Brad - Elephant opens tomorrow, 30 January, as it says on the front page blurb under the title of the review. :)

Mr_Gimp - There is one sequence in the film, after one of the killers has played a brilliant piece of Beethoven, where they play a violent videogame (which, incidentally, contains a reference to Van Sant's Gerry) but it rams no point down the viewer's throat. You are allowed to form your own opinion from all the evidence presented.
------
We do not tell time, time only tells us.
Quote this post
#7 Posted: 30-01-2004 03:05
bradavon
Banned
Posts: 2907

Report this post
Thanks Rik.
Quote this post
#8 Posted: 31-01-2004 13:59
Darth_Fisto
Account Disabled
Posts: 162

Report this post
Horrible film. Amatuer directing. And a completely disgusting story. To even bring a comparison between this and Bowling For Columbine is absurd because at least BFC had a point. Elephant gives no answers nor does it really contemplate them. A pointless film and a class-A example of poor filmmaking.
Quote this post
#9 Posted: 31-01-2004 14:10
Richard Booth
Contributor & Filmmaker
Posts: 980

Report this post
Of course it is a disgusting story - but Van Sant is only adapting what really happened, which was a tragedy. How else could it be presented?

And the directing is not amateur - there are some excellent shots in the film, and Elephant accomplishes what it sets out to achieve; it is not supposed to give any answers, instead provide a look at what the day would have been like.
------
We do not tell time, time only tells us.
Quote this post
#10 Posted: 03-02-2004 18:20
Darth_Fisto
Account Disabled
Posts: 162

Report this post
I was not refering to the content of the film as disgusting, but rather the way it was presented. Actions such as these are always met with disgust, but what is really disgusting is the attitude thrown towards the screen by the filmmakers. It's a good thing very few people will actually see this.
Quote this post
#11 Posted: 03-02-2004 21:45
Richard Booth
Contributor & Filmmaker
Posts: 980

Report this post
What attitude?
------
We do not tell time, time only tells us.
Quote this post
#12 Posted: 17-02-2004 21:21
Jace
Member
Posts: 130

Report this post
The French DVD slated for May is a 2-DVD set, with both Elephant (in its correct 1.33:1 aspect ratio) and the Alan Clark short film. Seems a far better purchase than the R1 barebones DVD.
Quote this post