Disc Specs

  • Region:
    2
  • Released:
    27th March 2006
  • Country:
    United Kingdom
  • Running Time:
    114 minutes
  • Screen Format:
    1.78:1 Anamorphic PAL
  • Discs / Sides / Layers:
    1 / 1 / Dual
  • Soundtracks:
    Japanese DD2.0
  • Subtitles:
    English (burnt-in)
  • Special Features:
    # 'Making of' Featurette (41 mins)
    # Theatrical Trailer
  • Distributor:
    Optimum

Film Specs

  • Certificate:
    15
  • Released:
    2001
  • Country:
    Japan
  • Director:
    Kiyoshi Kurosawa
  • Starring:
    Haruhiko Kato
    Kumiko Aso
    Koyuki
    Karume Arisaka
    Masatoshi Matsuo
    Shun Sugata
    Kenji Mizuhashi
  • Genre(s):
    Horror

Pulse

06-03-2006 00:00 | 4991 views  |  Anthony Nield  |  Show Backlinks

Of the two extras contained on this disc, perhaps the more noteworthy is the English language trailer. As you’d expect from such a piece there’s a great deal of hyperbole: Pulse is proclaimed as the true precursor to Japanese horror hits Ringu and Ju-on (The Grudge), whilst its director Kiyoshi Kurosawa is named the “godfather” of the current J-horror movement. Big words indeed, but almost entirely misplaced. They presume that the Japanese film industry didn’t make horror movies until the late nineties and that somehow Pulse, made in 2001, came before 1998’s Ringu. That said, Kurosawa’s efforts at least share some thematic and dramatic concerns with these other movies.. As with Ringu this is a film which sets up its ghost story via technological means. As with Ju-on it is essentially empty outside of its desire to elicit screams and scares.

It’s this latter element which seems to have taken precedent. Kurosawa favours slow, languorous build-ups followed by loud, heavily scored pay-offs. Cellos are preferred, as are the standard industrial rumbles, plus there’s room for what appears to be distorted church bells. All told, Kurosawa is able to create a fine atmosphere, one ably abetted by his choice of a muted colour scheme and equally low-key performances. The problem is that there’s so little behind it.

In plot terms Pulse can be a little muddy at times – following different characters for interminable periods of time leaves it feeling somewhat shapeless – yet essentially it revolves around a single concept. The ghost world - or whatever you may wish to call it – has, it seems, become overcrowded and so its inhabitants are beginning to make themselves known in the real world. Being a modern day J-horror movie this becomes apparent to our protagonists through various contemporary issues: a friend’s suicide sparks off their intrigue; the internet continues it; and even mobile phones are used as a means of ghostly communication.

All of which would no doubt have provided some interest had Kurosawa been in possession of some understanding of the issues he has chosen to raise. Yet we’re continually left with the impression that he doesn’t care for such things and as such they attain an almost tokenistic presence. Indeed, Pulse is simply marked by an all round attitude of technophobia, yet one which is present to such an extent that there’s never the interest on the filmmakers’ part with which to suck us in; they don’t care and so consequently neither do we, even as developments take a more apocalyptic turn.

Moreover, the decision to have the characters repeatedly talk to themselves and thus attempt explain the remotest of motivations (“What am I doing?” comes up time and again) suggests either that the filmmakers themselves don’t really know what’s going on or that they are treating their audience with contempt. Indeed, the end result is a film which not only do we not warm to, but also one that makes very little sense. As a final death knell, the fact that the market has since become overburdened by such films gives it very little currency, forthcoming US remake or not. Ultimately Pulse is nothing more than just another lacklustre Japanese horror movie.

The Disc

The disappointment is further compounded by Optimum’s less than worthy handling. The film itself comes in a ratio of 1.78:1, with anamorphic enhancement, but is otherwise lacking. The image suffers from soft edges and an overall murkiness, whilst the English subtitles are not only burnt-in, but also barely legible in their hazy, pure white form. As for the soundtrack, here we find a DD2.0 mix which is a noticeable downgrade from the intended DD5.1. It is admittedly fine as far as it goes, but not the kind of treatment we'd hope for or expect. Indeed, Pulse is coming to the UK market in somewhat unfavourable form and hardly likely to appeal to genre fans.

The extras amount to a 41-minute ‘making of’ featurette and the aforementioned trailer. Sadly, the lengthier piece shares the disappointment elsewhere. Opening with ten minutes worth of trailers and relying a great deal on B-roll footage, it comes across as a sprawling mess. Moreover, the interviews give away very little and certainly don’t explain any of Kurosawa’s choices or motivations. It’s hard not to come to the end of this piece (which also has burnt-in English subs, incidentally) and feel that Pulse was nothing more than another blatant cash-in on other directors’ successes.

DVD Times Ratings

  • Film:
    4
    4 out of 10
  • Video: 
    4
    4 out of 10
  • Audio: 
    6
    6 out of 10
  • Extras: 
    4
    4 out of 10
  • Overall: 
    4
    4 out of 10

Reader Ratings

  • Film 
    8
  • Video 
    0
  • Audio 
    0
  • Extras 
    0
  • Overall 
    0

Comments

#1 Posted: 06-03-2006 08:57
napalm68
Member
Posts: 281

Report this post
God damn joke with the video transfer. The HK version is not too bad. The extra would be nice, but not worth buying a cruddier transfer.:mad:
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 06-03-2006 09:40
evilcat
Member
Posts: 58

Report this post
I always thought the point of this film was that people are, in the end, truly alone. Even when dead, there's no heaven, there's no acceptance, just eternal loneliness. And that these lonely dead were attempting to encourage all the living to join them.

Although people say otherwise, I feel this is the weakest of Kurosawa's three key films (the other two being Kourei/Seance and Cure). The apocalyptic elements are extremely well done though.

A question to Anthony: when the Plane comes down, do you hear any SFX? This was removed from all versions on DVD released after September 11th 2001.

I got the HK R3 for HK$25 and it was worth every penny. Don't feel the film deserves a 4, but I'd give it a 6 or a 7... The other two I've mentioned are better.
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 06-03-2006 09:44
anield
Contributor
Posts: 47

Report this post
Evilcat: I don't recall hearing anything at all during the scene with the plane, though I'll go back to the disc and check to make sure.
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 06-03-2006 11:11
bradavon
Banned
Posts: 2907

Report this post
Personally I think this film is tops. I was lucky to see it on the big screen while in Thailand and found it very effective. It's one of the best in the genre. It's a shame the film has been treated so badly on DVD.

I'm not convinced DD5.1 is intended. Only the HK DVD has DD5.1, the R1, UK R2 and most importantly Japanese R2 all have DD2.0 only.

That said the DD5.1 is very effective and I for one wouldn't want to lose it. I was considering getting this for the extras but now they sound like a mess I'm not bothered.

Madman on R4 have the rights to this so fingers crossed they'll beat this. The R1 incidentally looks to be exactly the same on paper as this UK R2.

Quote:
A question to Anthony: when the Plane comes down, do you hear any SFX?

I never knew that. I saw it in 2002 and it was silent during that scene I thought it was deliberate and actually added to the atmosphere. I seem to remember the next suddenly being very loud it really throws you off course.
Quote this post
#5 Posted: 06-03-2006 15:34
tokyomonkey
Member
Posts: 269

Report this post
Wonderful film-Bought the Japanese R2 when it came out after being impressed by Korosawa's earlier films,Cure and Charisma.
Quote this post
#6 Posted: 06-03-2006 18:38
Slarek
Member
Posts: 74

Report this post
A superb film and one that, as has been rightly observed elsewhere, is one of the most thoughtful and intelligent studies of loneliness and isolation yet committed to celluloid. This is WAY more than just another Japanese horror movie. Once again, there is no way the American remake will come close to the subtlety and effectiveness of the original.

I personally found the 5.1 track REALLY effective. Having a spirit hoarsely whisper "Tasukete!" ("Help!") suddenly right behind my head scared the living daylights out of me.
Quote this post
#7 Posted: 06-03-2006 19:32
Robin Davies
Member
Posts: 21

Report this post
Spot on Slarek. This is one of the most atmospheric and chilling movies I've ever seen and Kurosawa is the best of the current Japanese directors in my book.
Quote this post
#8 Posted: 06-03-2006 21:12
Phil Q
Member
Posts: 1815

Report this post
Got to agree with the last few posts. Slarek's said it all, it's a wonderful film. And the sound design is bloody terrifying.
Quote this post
#9 Posted: 07-03-2006 19:29
Lord Retsudo
Member
Posts: 10

Report this post
I very rarely feel the need to comment on reviews, but in this case I felt I had to... I think Kurosawa is the best (or at least, most interesting) director working in Japan today, and would rate CURE as the best Japanese film of the late 90's. Admittedly, I wouldn't rank PULSE as one of his greatest achievements, but it's nowhere near as bad as is made out in this review. To describe it as "nothing more than just another lacklustre Japanese horror movie" when there is so much more going on than is typical of the genre defies belief!

It's a great shame that more of Kurosawa's oeuvre work isn't available in the West - THE SERPENT'S PATH and THE EYES OF THE SPIDER in particular are fascinating.
Quote this post
#10 Posted: 09-03-2006 18:08
mordo
Member
Posts: 10

Report this post
Indeed PULSE is the pinnacle of all this everywhere-emitting long-hair -horror. With depth and substance for a dozen average ones. ...and of course bloody creepy. But really, IMO Kurosawa has nothing to do with the commercial J-horror movement as his films work in a totally different -and intelligent- sphere.

The Japanese R2 DVD has audio/SFX in the plane crash.
Quote this post
#11 Posted: 10-03-2006 14:48
ggfletch
Part-Time Vagabond
Posts: 62

Report this post
I'm afraid I have to echo the sentiments of the pro-Pulse camp, Anthony. I think you've written it off far too easily. It's a wonderfully inventive metaphysical horror film, with something much more interesting to say than the huge raft of sub-par J-Horror that we've become accustomed to over the last few years.

For fans: Check out Licence to Live, if you haven't seen it - a wonderful little gem of a film from our boy, Kiyoshi.
Quote this post

Do you have a Times Network ID or DVD Times account? Sign in now!



Username:
Password:
Remember:


If not, why not register for one now and experience all the benefits of being a Times Network Member.