Related Content

Disc Specs

  • Region:
    2
  • Released:
    24 November 2003
  • Country:
    United Kingdom
  • Running Time:
    109 minutes
  • Screen Format:
    1.85:1 Anamorphic PAL
  • Discs / Sides / Layers:
    1 / 1 / Dual
  • Soundtracks:
    Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0
  • Subtitles:
    English (optional)

  • Special Features:
    Takeshi Kitano interview
    Miho Kanno interview
    Hidetoshi Nishijima interview
    Yohji Yamamoto interview
    Monzaemon Chikamatsu
    Bunraku
    Takeshi Kitano Biography
    Theatrical Trailer
  • Distributor:
    Artificial Eye

Film Specs

  • Certificate:
    12
  • Released:
    2002
  • Country:
    Japan
  • Director:
    Takeshi Kitano
  • Starring:
    Miho Kanno
    Hidetoshi Nishijima
    Tatsuya Mihashi
    Chieko Matsubara
    Kyoko Fukada
    Tsutomu Takeshige
  • Genre(s):
    Drama

Dolls

27-12-2003 10:00 | 13760 views  |  Noel Megahey  |  Show Backlinks

Dolls is a kind of reverse Bunraku film – a Japanese puppet film where the puppets become the spectators and the humans act out three dramatic and poetic tales of love, loss and tragedy.


Matsumoto (Hidetoshi Nishijima) is pushed into an arranged marriage with the daughter of the boss, but when he hears that the girlfriend he has jilted, Sawaka (Miho Kanno) has attempted to commit suicide, he leaves his bride-to-be at the altar. He takes Sawaka from the hospital where she is being looked after and together they wander the country. To keep the mentally disturbed girl from wandering off, he keeps her attached to him with a red silk rope. The couple become known as the ‘bound beggars’ and as the seasons pass by they come across other similar tragic love stories.

An aging yakuza boss (Tatsuya Mihashi) visits the park where he last saw the girlfriend he abandoned as a young man in the pursuit of success. The woman (Chieko Matsubara), now much older also, still keeps her promise and waits for him on the same park bench every Saturday with a lunch she has made for him, hoping that one day he will come back to her.


A glamorous pop-star Haruna Yamaguchi (Kyoko Fukada) is disfigured in a car accident and goes into hiding from the world. Her biggest fan, Nukui (Tsutomu Takeshige) blinds himself when he hears of the accident.

There is a delightful, typically Japanese ambiguity to the characters and their situation. The characters are not lovers whose lives have been ruined by some strange twist of fate – they themselves are responsible for their own predicaments and the circumstances that they are faced with. Their actions have all been taken of their own freewill and mistakes have been made through their own egotism and vanity. What they can never do is recover what has been lost and they know this – this is their tragedy. Instead of looking back on their mistake with regret, each of the characters attempts to make reparation in a strange way. The gestures are false and completely pointless, motivated perhaps more by an attempt to regain face and dignity than through any selfless action. Yet we are being asked to and can’t help but sympathise with the beautiful, poetic penitence that they each put themselves through, facing up to their past mistakes. Not since In The Mood For Love has there been a film that was so devastatingly simple, yet so painfully beautiful.




Video
The photography in the film is breathtaking. Each season is hyper-stylised – a blaze of colours, rich and warm, marks out each of the seasons depicted in the film. The film’s transfer to DVD bears this out superbly with a perfect balance of brightness and contrast letting the colours dominate. The image is sharp and clear - impressively so, with only the slightest hint of grain which does no harm to the film whatsoever. I noticed a faint judder when there was movement in scenes at the start and end of the film and some minor signs of compression artefacts, but otherwise there isn’t a mark on the print and the film looks colourful and sharp.


Audio
The soundtrack is Dolby Digital 2.0. I don’t understand Artificial Eye’s policy with soundtracks. They make every effort to ensure that every release is presented anamorphically where possible at the correct aspect ratio, yet they don’t apply the same standard to the soundtrack. Several other international releases of the film have the original surround track presented on a Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack. I don’t know if presenting it in 2.0 makes much of a difference to the film but it is surely not as the director intended. This isn’t the only reason for the low scoring for the soundtrack however. The soundtrack is ever so slightly out of sync for about the first half-hour of the film, fixing itself by the middle, only to go out of sync again towards the end. This is the third Artificial Eye release in the last few months to have lip-sync problems – Russian Ark and Springtime In A Small Town also suffered from similar problems to a greater or lesser degree. It is not terribly noticeable here, but it should be spotted and corrected before a DVD is released – quality control is failing somewhere along the line here.

Subtitles
English subtitles read well and are optional.

Extras
There are a number of good interviews among the extra features on the disc. The first Takeshi Kitano interview (15:23) covers the inspiration of the film, its Bunraku connection and the film’s style. The second Takeshi Kitano interview (14:26) focuses on the characters’ motivations and general questions on themes in the film. Kitano’s answers are invariably short, but to the point and he makes a number of interesting observations. There are also short interviews with the ‘bound beggar’ actors Miho Kanno (03:55) and Hidetoshi Nishijima (03:43) who talk about their characters and demonstrate their complete awe for the director. There is also an interview with fashion designer Yohji Yamamoto (10:06) who created the costume designs that give the film much of its character. Some useful text features provide some background information on Monzaemon Chikamatsu (1653 - 1724), the most famous author of Bunraku plays and some background information on Bunraku puppets and performance. There is also a Takeshi Kitano Biography providing a look at one of the most colourful and diverse talents in international cinema. A Theatrical Trailer (01:38), letterboxed, is also included among this strong and relevant selection of extra features.



Overall
Kitano continues to make films which challenge the viewer’s expectations and widen his own filmmaking abilities. Dolls is a striking example of various levels of storytelling and treatments of a theme. It can be enjoyed on purely the most simple aesthetic level as a stunningly composed and beautifully photographed work, yet it works on many other, sometimes contradictory, levels. It works as both a tribute to traditional Japanese storytelling and a reaction against the romanticism of those stories and the viewer is free to choose whichever interpretation they like. Whichever way you look at it though, this is a beautiful, graceful, thoughtful and considered work of art.

DVD Times Ratings

  • Film:
    9
    9 out of 10
  • Video: 
    9
    9 out of 10
  • Audio: 
    6
    6 out of 10
  • Extras: 
    7
    7 out of 10
  • Overall: 
    8
    8 out of 10

Reader Ratings

  • Film 
    9
  • Video 
    0
  • Audio 
    0
  • Extras 
    0
  • Overall 
    0

Comments

#1 Posted: 30-12-2003 23:28
bradavon
Banned
Posts: 2907

Report this post
Thanks for this review. The Japanese DVD is too expensive and the Korean/HK DVD's are non-anamorphic making this the second winner IMO (but like the Japanese DVD they do have DD5.1).

What do you mean by:

"fixing itself by the middle"
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 31-12-2003 09:25
Noel M
Contributor
Posts: 485

Report this post
There is a slight lip-sync problem at the start of the film. After about half an hour it is no longer noticeable, so it has fixed itself, as if it was running at a different speed to the picture. The problem re-occurs towards the end of the film, but is less noticeable.
------


DVD Times Reviewer
Best DVDs 2008 | All My Reviews

Quote this post
#3 Posted: 03-01-2004 00:53
Matthijs
Member
Posts: 1

Report this post
Sure about the new Korean dvd being non-anamorphic? Yesasia lists it as being anamorph, but i'm not really willing to believe that until someone has confirmation ;) I've never heard of the company "Line Tree Entertainment" either...
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 04-01-2004 16:51
Slarek
Member
Posts: 74

Report this post
There is one short sequence in the first story where the lip sync is deliberately off - the voices and visuals are from different memories and it was the same in the cinema. Other than that, my disk (and player) has the sync bang on throughout.
Quote this post
#5 Posted: 04-01-2004 21:44
Noel M
Contributor
Posts: 485

Report this post
I know the sequence you are referring to - it's Matumoto's confrontation about the wedding with his parents. That is obviously meant to be out of sync as the images are slowed down. The problem with the disc I was sent out to review is more widespread than that. It particularly noticeable when doors slam or footsteps don't match movements. I've checked this on two different players. I would welcome opinions from anyone else who has the Artificial Eye disc.
------


DVD Times Reviewer
Best DVDs 2008 | All My Reviews

Quote this post
#6 Posted: 05-01-2004 07:54
Slarek
Member
Posts: 74

Report this post
I will double check my disk. As a (not perfect) Japanese speaker I tend not to rely on subtitles much of the time so do notice more when lip-sync is out, and don't recall those faults, but will give the disk another look tonight with that in mind.
Quote this post
#7 Posted: 11-01-2004 14:14
Slarek
Member
Posts: 74

Report this post
I did take another look, this time on the DVD drive on my computer, and by carefully scrutinising the first half-hour I did notice a couple of minor possible sync drifts on dialogue, but to be honest these look more like ADR issues than a consistent sync error on the print. I also spotted at least one occasion when the picture and sound were, I believe, deliberately run at different speeds, a filmic trick for a fractured memory recall. I guess the only way to check would be to compare the disk with the region 3 or, better still, catch it in the cinema again. I'd love this, of course, but since I had to organise the only screening that took place even remotely near where I live, this is unlikely. Lovely film, though. REALLY looking forward to 'Zatoichi' (and I'm a big fan of the original).
Quote this post
#8 Posted: 22-01-2004 14:05
Geert Jan
Member
Posts: 17

Report this post
I saw the Artificial Eye version too yesterday and the audio was definitely out of sync most of the time. :(

Beautiful movie though. :)

So, who can confirm that the Korean DVD is anamorphic? That Japanese one looks a wee bit expensive.
Quote this post
#9 Posted: 24-02-2004 19:15
kb
Member
Posts: 2

Report this post
This might come a bit late, but here's some info about the Korean release of Dolls:

Aspect: NON-anamorphic, letterboxed
Sound: DD5.1
Subtitles: Korean, Chinese, English
Region: 0
Extra features: none

The DVD comes with six pictures from the movie, printed on photo-like paper
Besides being non-anamorphic, the picture has some other slight problems, although for me, it was acceptable. The thing that bugged me most was that the subtitles were partially on top of the black bar at the bottom of the picture, which forces you to slightly squish the image on a 16:9 TV so that you can see the subs.
------
Korean movies: http://www.the-isle.org
Quote this post
#10 Posted: 09-03-2004 17:55
Geert Jan
Member
Posts: 17

Report this post
Thanks kb, very helpful. :cool:

(But now I want the Japanese DVD which is so expensive! :()
Quote this post
#11 Posted: 03-08-2004 18:58
mortontrerms
Member
Posts: 8

Report this post
The image on this release is cropped by 3% either side and 8% at the bottom (see www.dvdbeaver.com).
Quote this post

Do you have a Times Network ID or DVD Times account? Sign in now!



Username:
Password:
Remember:


If not, why not register for one now and experience all the benefits of being a Times Network Member.